We’re net positive again in 2014!

We used 8,108 kWh and generated 8,348 kWh for a net of 240 kWh for the year. The combination of cold temperatures, less sun and the plug-in Prius brought us close to our net point. Here’s our progress for our first 3 years in the house.

Usage Solar PV Net usage
or (surplus)
Avg.
daily usage
HDD
Total 20,914 25,779 (4,864) 19.1 19,758
2012 5,601 8,856 (3,256) 15.3 5,885
2013 7,206 8,575 (1,368) 19.7 6,810
2014 8,101 8,348 (240) 22.2 7,063

Q4 2014 summary: 7% warmer, 8% less usage and 25% less sun as compared to Q4 2013.

In Q4 last year our total usage was 1,957 kWh. This year is was 1,802 kWh, a 8% decrease. Snow covering the collectors for 8 days and cloudy weather resulted in 24% less energy production in Q4.

Overall, here’s how this quarter and the year compare to 2013.

Charts comparing Q4 usage, solar and HDD

2014 Usage Solar PV Net usage
or (surplus)
Avg.
daily usage
HDD
Total 1,802 1,186 616 19.6 2,213
Oct
413 538 (125) 13.3 373
Nov
570 400 170 19.0 807
Dec
819 248 571 26.7 1,033
2013 Usage Solar PV Net usage
or (surplus)
Avg.
daily usage
HDD
Total 1,957 1,576 380 21.3 2,372
Oct
482 674 (192) 15.6 405
Nov
559 639 (81) 18.6 838
Dec
916 263 653 29.5 1,129
All values in kWh (except HDD which is base 65°F).

Year over year comparison

Chart comparing year over year usage

I like to compare the energy we use each year excluding heat. Our little story chart above, shows our usage and how it has played out over the last 3 years. By far our biggest energy increases have been related to hatching and brooding chickens and turkeys each spring. We managed to raise a year+ worth of chicken and turkeys this year, not to mention all the milk and cheese from the goats. It would of course be cheaper to buy chicken, eggs, milk and cheese, and Thanksgiving turkey at the store, but we like to do things the hard way.

Pie chart - circuit breakdown

We started monitoring an additional 11 circuits in March when we switched to eGuage, but I haven’t had a chance to look at that data in any detail yet. The main changes this year, are increased usage of the ASHP and the ‘everything else’ category which included the Prius plugin for eight and a half months. I’ve also started tracking the vampire loads from things like the induction cooktop & stove, solar inverter and the ASHP. These are things you can’t just unplug. In total these 3 appliances used a minimum of 119 kWh to do nothing. I say minimum because I have only been able to start tracking some of these vampire loads with our new energy monitor starting in March.

Chart showing net zero break even point

This year I started plotting when we net out on energy use versus production. I call it the ‘net zero moment’. This year it happened about 2 months later than last year. Thankfully we didn’t cross over again in December.

Chart showing cumulative kWh used by ASHP Oct-Dec 2012-2014

Last year I noticed that our air-source heat pump (ASHP) used a lot more energy (114% more) in 2013 than in 2012. 2013 was cooler than 2012 but it was also sunnier. I never figured out the increase. This year, the ASHP also used more energy than last year despite being 7% warmer. Both the lack of sun (25% less) and our change in use of the thermostat most likely had the biggest impact. In 2013 I turned the heat off at night. This was generally fine until we had a few days below zero and the heat pump was not able to make up the difference. So this year I tried leaving the unit on and just turning it down to 65F at night. I think this has increased our usage without any real gain in comfort. It seems like it’s really only important to keep the unit on if the next day’s temperatures are known to be below zero, which is where our ASHP has trouble keeping up with demand.

Chart showing kWh used by ASHP in 10 degree buckets

Speaking of ASHP usage, here is our plot showing the amount of energy we used for each 10 degree drop in temperature. If you remember the post from last year, 2013 looks a little different. I realized the ASHP vampire load was throwing off my count of hours. This year I only show hours where the unit was actually doing something, heating or cooling the house. We had substantially more hours below 50 degrees. Most of the ASHP usage has consistently occurred in the 20-30 degree range.

Chart comparing water usage 2012-2014

We seem to be fairly consistent in our hot water usage. Over the year we’re averaging 18.4 gallons/day. That hot water requires 262 watts/gallon to heat. Cold water usage averages at 43.5 gallons/day. In total we used 22,575 gallons on water in 2014. It took 58 kWh to pump that water out of the ground. I’m guessing half of that is water for the various assortment of critters on the farm. They don’t drink a lot, but they do waste a lot.

Chart comparing temperature ranges 2013-2014

And lastly, just because I like this chart, the temperature ranges we experienced this year. In case it is not clear, 2014 was 0.9154149°F warmer on average than 2013.

Happy 2015!

You can see heat maps and detailed charts of temperature and electrical usage at netplusdesign.com. View hourly, daily and monthly values for solar, usage, net usage, temperatures and HDD.

Detailed data finally available again

We changed energy monitors in March and the new data format broke my database scripts, but I finally found time to update my scripts and publish* our hourly data for the period March to November. One thing I noticed immediately was that I had been sloppy in my reporting of energy use for that time period. I used the UI to select dates and didn’t realize I wasn’t getting the most accurate timeframe. As a result, I’m going to post an updated energy record at the end of January for the entire year.

Good news, we’re still on track to produce more energy than we used for 2014, but it is going to be a squeaker. At the end of November we had a revised 829 kWh in the bank. As of today, December 19, at 11:31 am Eastern time, we had used 495 kWh and generated 115 kWh for a net usage of 380 kWh. We have roughly 12 and a half days left and 449 kWh left in the bank.

The solar panels have been covered in snow 8 days day this month and our average usage is 26.7 kWh/day. So even if we had no sun the rest of the month and continued our average usage, we’d use 347 kWh leaving us with just 102 kWh to spare. Thankfully, we’ll get a little sunlight on the panels and the forecast is warmer next week. Fingers crossed.

* Detailed data available at NetPlusDesign.

Sol LeWitt inspired doodles

After seeing the Sol LeWitt Retrospective at Mass MoCA last weekend, I felt the need to do some computational doodling today.

Lines

Curves

Small fat curves (Holiday Microbe)

Curve receding

More curve

Loopy Doopy (inspired) in color

 

100 lines, none straight, some touching

I produced all images using Processing.

Apply for the 2015 NESEA Zero Net Energy Building Award

Just saw this post on the NESEA site go up yesterday. Looks like they are now accepting entries for the 2015 award.

If you have built or live in a home that has produced more energy than it uses in the last year, then I encourage you to enter the competition. They have worked to make the application process a bit easier this year and the benefits of winning include not only the prize money, but also a chance to meet some of the leading proponents and practitioners of building net zero structures at the yearly conference when they announce the winner. You also get your building’s picture on the cover of BuildingEnergy magazine.

I highly recommend you apply, it is well worth the effort. Do it quickly, the deadline is December 15.

Good luck!

Designing and building your own net zero home

We wrote this article in June for the Fall 2014 issue of BuildingEnergy Magazine. Edited by Mark J. McCourt.

Designing and building your own home can be a huge challenge. It can be even more daunting if you set your sights on a high performance home that will produce more power each year than it uses. Thankfully, there are a ton of resources online—at times too many—that can help make those challenges more manageable. I am not, however, suggesting that any homeowner can do this without considerable learning or prior design build experience.

Jill and I are both designers. Jill works in graphic design and I work in the technology industry to make online applications easier and more intuitive to use. I studied architecture in school and paid for college in the early years by working for builders and a mason. It wasn’t out of concern for the budget that we did not hire an architect; in fact, an architect experienced in high performance homes would have likely saved us time and money. We simply wanted to do it ourselves because we enjoy the challenge and we had confidence we could do it well. We also knew when to ask for help.

We hired DEAP Group to estimate our peak heating load, specify our ventilation requirements and estimate how much solar we would need to achieve net zero. They also offered a number of recommendations that boosted our efficiency further. Please do not rely on anyone without experience in high performance homes to do this type of work for you; our energy star rater had zero experience with homes of our type. Based on their calculations, the heating load would have been half DEAP’s estimate, and our total usage would have been twice DEAP’s estimate. If we had followed our energy star estimate, we would have needed a 12 kW system to net out. Our first year actuals came very close to DEAP’s estimate.

One of our most important decisions was picking a contractor. Ideally we wanted someone that had experience building a net zero home, but there was no one in our rural area. We found W.R. Coolidge and Co., an experienced builder next door, that was interested in high performance homes and was eager to learn with us. Most importantly, he was willing to let us do as much of the work as we felt comfortable doing ourselves, and show us how to do it right.

Since we were involved in every decision and I had built detailed 3D models of almost every house system and detail, it was easy for us to coordinate the work of the contractors responsible for the foundation, electrical, plumbing, HVAC, cellulose insulation and solar PV installation. All of this required a great deal of time, research and planning; it is one of the reasons it took us more than 18 months to complete the house.

Throughout the process we posted much of our thinking and analysis in our blog, uphillhouse.com. The technology community places a great deal of value on open-source work. Sharing your work has several benefits: it creates opportunities for others to comment and make suggestions for improvements; it makes it easier for others to follow in your footsteps with less risk and more confidence; and most importantly, the act of sharing requires you to explain what you’re doing and why, in simple and clear terms. This forces you to think things through much more carefully. If your logic or calculation has a flaw, you want to make sure you find it before you tell the world about it.

After we moved in, we installed sensors to track the performance of our home. All our data is posted online at netplusdesign.com, for anyone to view and analyze. We collect and post our data for several reasons. We believe data should be open and accessible so that others can benefit from our experience. We want to know how the house actually performs, as compared to the estimates. We want to prove whether we have met our goals or not; if we have not, then we need to understand why.

We have been extremely lucky. It is a very comfortable home even in the deepest, coldest days and months of an upstate New York winter. In our first two years living in the house, we produced more energy than we used, despite the addition of a barn, dairy goats, chickens, turkeys, other assorted critters and a plug-in hybrid vehicle. This year, winter temperatures were much colder, and we are attempting to raise more of our own food, both of which use more energy. Last year, we passed into net positive territory in early June. This year we were still 1,121 kWh short at the end of May, a 1,000 kWh difference from 2013. We still expect us to generate a surplus in 2014, but it will be close.

So don’t go it alone unless you’re prepared to invest a significant amount of time researching and learning the nuances of high-performance building. If you don’t have 100 percent confidence in what you’re doing and why, it’s too easy for contractors to convince you that it’s too hard or too expensive to do it that way. Your house will suffer from a thousand small decisions that will ultimately undo your original goal: to live more sustainably in a net-zero home.

Larry & Jill

We’re on the cover of BuildingEnergy magazine!

Pic of BuildingEnergy Magazine

We’re on the cover of Building Energy magazine, Fall 2014.

There is a description of the entries to the 2014 Zero Net Energy Building Award, and an article we wrote to go along with our entry.

It’s not available online yet, but when it is, it should be available from the NESEA BuildingEnergy Magazine page.

* Note to magazine editor, the last name is Burks, not Burk. The home is in New York, not New Hampshire. CFM stands for Cubic Feet per Minute, not Cubic Feet per Meter.

Entry door lock sets replaced

Pic of corroded door lock mechanism (closeup) Pic of corroded door lock mechanism

Why am I writing about our entry door locks? We’ve had problems with our entry door locks every winter. They freeze up and it’s impossible to get the key in the key hole. Now they are so corroded inside that the lock mechanism barely works the rest of the year. They are less than 3 years old. I was surprised to see the amount of corrosion inside.

I’ve spoken to a few people about our frozen door locks in the winter. The issue seems to be that the house is so tight, that warm moist air inside the house only has one place to get out, through the key holes. One other consideration. Our ERV is set by default to produce a very small increase in internal air pressure. I believe their thought is that you want to be pushing clean air out the leaks, rather than pulling unconditioned air in. But I believe this may be one of the sources of our problem.

I’ve installed new door entry sets and will be setting the ERV to fully balanced to see if this solves our problem this winter.

I haven’t seen anyone else mention this problem, so I thought I would post here and see if anyone else with a passivhaus-level tight home has had this experience.  Please comment below if you have, and what you did to fix it.


Latest Uphill Tweets

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 188 other followers

Check out our farm blog!